[contact-form-7 404 "Not Found"]
Log in

Five Studies, One Conclusion: Creative Drives Performance

  Go back to Blog

Aurelie Touboul
Published on 30 April 2026


  • share

Every year, marketers pour billions into media planning and audience targeting.

And yet, five major industry studies — spanning hundreds of campaigns and multiple geographies — all arrive at the same conclusion.

The evidence has been building for years, across methodologies, geographies, and media channels.
Nielsen Catalina, Kantar, WARC, Yahoo/IPG Magna, Ekimetrics/Google — organizations with no particular agenda to romanticize creativity — have all arrived at the same conclusion:

Creative quality is the highest-leverage variable available to advertisers. 

What follows is a synthesis of five major industry studies.

1/ Creative drives 49% of sales impact – Nielsen Catalina Solutions(“Five Keys to Ad Effectiveness”) – 2018

According to Nielsen Catalina Solutions study — nearly 500 campaigns across all media platforms — creative is the single most powerful driver of sales performance, accounting for 47% of total sales contribution.

That’s more than reach, brand, targeting, recency, and context combined.

The core takeaways for marketers:

  • No media plan saves bad creative. Media optimization cannot compensate for weak creative — but strong creative makes media almost secondary.
  • Creative’s weight varies by channel: 37% of sales contribution in TV vs. 56% in digital (video, display & mobile).
  • Digital amplifies the stakes: Both TV and digital share the same median creative productivity ($0.08), but the variance is far wider in digital (±$0.21 vs. ±$0.12) — meaning great creative wins bigger online, and bad creative fails harder.

The bottom line: creative quality is not a “soft” priority. It is, quantifiably, the highest-leverage investment available to advertisers.

2/ Creative quality: profit multiplier 12X – Kantar & Paul Dyson Collaboration – 2020

In 2020, a Kantar/Paul Dyson analysis — combining econometric modelling with Kantar’s brand, media and creative databases — ranks the key factors driving advertising profitability by their actual impact (profitability multiplier). 

The finding: marketers are systematically investing in the wrong priorities.

Creative quality: multiplier 12x — ranked #4 by marketers (44%). The gap between the best and worst ads is dramatic. Award-winning creative isn’t enough — the best ads are both creative and effectively branded.

What marketers over-prioritize:

  • Media mix optimization, brand vs. performance balance, and targeting — all real levers, but with far lower profitability multipliers (1.1x to 2.5x).

The bottom line: No amount of media sophistication compensates for a weak brand or a weak ad.

3/ High creative quality → 6.62X more profit – Kantar & WARC Evidence (“The Art of Proof”) – 2023

A 2023 Kantar/WARC study — matching ~450 ads across both databases (250,000+ ads tested via Kantar Link; 1,100+ WARC ROI case studies) — puts a hard number on what great creative is worth.

The finding is simple and striking:

  • Low creative quality → 1.42x average ROMI (Return On Marketing Investment) profit
  • Middle creative quality → 3.96x
  • High creative quality → 6.62x

High-quality creative generates more than 4x the profit of low-quality creative.

Two things make this study particularly robust:

  • Kantar’s Link methodology has been validated over 30 years and is the only ad testing tool recognized by the Marketing Accountability Standards Board (MASB)
  • Creative quality was measured on both short-term sales likelihood and long-term brand demand — meaning the profit gap holds across time horizons, not just immediate response

The bottom line: in a context of tightening budgets, creative quality is the highest-ROI variable a marketer controls. Cutting corners on creative testing doesn’t save money — it destroys it.

4/ +12 percentage points on purchase intent – Yahoo & IPG/Magna Global Study (“Creative, The Performance Powerhouse”) – 2023

A Yahoo/IPG Magna Global study cuts through a long-standing debate in digital advertising: what actually drives brand KPIs — creative quality or media placement & targeting?

The answer is unambiguous:

  • Top-of-mind ad recall: Creative 79% vs. Media placement 21%
  • Brand favorability: Creative 77% vs. Media placement 23%
  • Purchase intent: Creative 56% vs. Media placement 44%

Beyond the split, quality creative also moves brand perception directly vs. base ads:

  • +7% perceive the brand as “high quality”
  • +8% perceive the brand as “trustworthy”
  • +12 percentage points on purchase intent

As MAGNA EVP Kara Manatt put it plainly: “No amount of great media can perform well if creative is mediocre.”

The bottom line: media targeting gets your ad in front of the right person. Creative determines what happens next. 

5/ Improve YouTube ROI by 1.7X – Ekimetrics x Google Study (“Mastering Creative Excellence on YouTube in Europe”) – 2025/2026

A 2025 Ekimetrics/Google study — analyzing 778 YouTube videos across 9 brands in automotive, beauty, and hospitality — used a rare combination of Marketing Mix Modeling and machine learning to quantify exactly what creative execution is worth in video advertising.

The headline number:

  • Improving creative quality from “poor” to “optimal” multiplies YouTube ROI by 1.7x
  • Only 15% of European YouTube videos are classified as “optimal” — and half don’t even apply 3 of the 13 key principles. The gap between best practice and reality is massive.

The practical implication: creative excellence on YouTube is not about bigger budgets — it’s about applying the right principles consistently. A clear call-to-action alone can meaningfully shift conversion rates.

The bottom line: on YouTube, creative quality is still the primary differentiation lever — and most European advertisers are leaving significant ROI on the table.

One final word

“If your creative is currently responsible for over half of your purchase intent, is it receiving more than half of your strategic attention?” 

Want to see what creative intelligence looks like in practice?

Book a demo with VideoRunRun — and turn your creative signals into measurable performance impact.

Stay ahead

Subscribe to receive updates on videorunrun and how video is making waves in the industry